One of these sold just two months ago for ~$302, so this ending price represents a serious escalation in perceived value by at least two bidders. These surface enough that I feel the prevailing bidder vastly overpaid.
This fearsome bat decoration was produced by Gibson during the 1930s. It is an odd amalgamation of expertly designed bat body with such forgettable, plain wings they seem almost an afterthought. That mismatch has caused prices for this design to be modest, especially compared to Gibson’s winged owl decorations.
Whomever was lucky enough to swoop in and acquire this lot for the laughably low price of $90 should be doing a happy dance for eternity. The Gibson tombstone diecut alone is one of the most highly coveted products made by that firm. Listed alone, it would have easily brought multiples of what the entire lot brought. The large piece to the left is part of Dennison’s Hobgoblinville set.
It’s interesting to see this variant Gibson party sign. The fact that the head is severed from the main body and then so amateurishly repaired is unfortunate. Who would have guessed that Gibson made at least two versions of this cool diecut?
This was produced by Gibson, not Dennison. It is a hard-to-find item with a mechanical feature.
09/12 Update: This brought $166.50.
This great set rarely surfaces in what the seller describes as mint condition. Typically, one or more of the connecting tabs are long gone. This dancing cat centerpiece was produced by Gibson during the later 1920s. The seller received a healthy price for this, but I wonder if the ending price might have even been higher had she started the auction with a significantly lower threshold.
Wow, I never imagined a world where this delicate and rare candle transparency would have sold for $450! I love the photos this fine seller included, as I’ve always had difficulty imagining how this was supposed to be used.
08/28 Update: Another example by a different seller sold on 08/25 for $100 - the vagaries of eBay!
This complete Gibson centerpiece was produced during the 1920s. It almost never comes on the market intact as one or more of the end tabs are generally missing. This is a fun piece with a lot of energy. It makes a stunning display.
08/08 Update: This sold for $302, a recent high for this set.
Gibson diecuts, once definite also-rans to those made by Dennison and Beistle, have been rapidly escalating in value these past 2 years. Collectors have woken up to their rich colors and designs, their eccentricity and most of all to their scarcity. This is one of my favorite of their diecuts. Few of Gibson’s diecut designs surface regularly, especially not in this condition. I’d love to know how many of each design comprised this drugstore find. Guide value is $175, but since this market segment has moved much faster than I ever expected it to do, I expect the final price to exceed that figure. This was made during the early 1930s.
08/08 Update: This sold for $372.
It’s great to see this colorful tally produced by Gibson during the 1920s listed on eBay - especially by such a fine seller. I recently posted the matching nut cup and place card to this design on my Acquisitions section of the site. The major holiday paper manufacturers typically issued their designs in four pieces: invitation, tally, place card and nut cup.
04/02 Update: This great tally sold for $39.88.
Even if these two were in perfect condition, I feel the ending price isn’t sustainable. Of course, the condition of these diecuts is poor overall given that one is missing a chunk and the other has significant general soiling. These skull diecuts were produced by Gibson during the early 1930s. They also made them in white. See page 169.
This small paper item was made by Gibson.
01/17 Update: This seldom-seen diecut brought a strong $222.50.
Now, this is one helluva freaky, fantastic diecut. When I first saw this Gibson listing, I prayed that it would be in collectible condition. I was disappointed when it fell far short of the acceptable threshold for my collection. This is precisely the kind of odd imagery and disorienting colors I eat up. I contacted the seller who stated this was the sole example of this diecut she had available. My decision was easy not to try for it. (The ending price of $610 blew me away. I sure am glad I began collecting 30 years ago, as collecting truly vintage Halloween is rapidly becoming a hobby for the wealthy!) I will add it to my very short “Holy Grail” list and hope one comes my way.
This Gibson party sign diecut with their classic signature slanted exclamation point went for FAR more than I would have guessed. Prices tend to moderate at this stage of the season, but I haven’t seen much evidence of this usual trend this year. This seller had several wonderful diecuts - all of which sold for astronomical prices. Given the final photo in all of her listings, I am curious how many of each will be on offer over time.
This desirable shade was produced by Gibson during the 1930s. Gibson seems to have the monopoly on using teepees as part of Halloween iconography!
10/18 Update: This sold for $155.27.