This seller has gotten so many results of late that are so far out of line with long-established values that she has become the subject of much conversation. This game is not uncommon. (I see that another eBay seller immediately listed this game in a similar condition for a BIN of $625 once this listing ended. It’ll be interesting to see if it sells.) I would be thrilled to sell any item I have as part of the collection for the price this seller has recently obtained! So, ASK. I have never seen anything like this. In a recent email exchange with the seller, she states that she starts everything at $9.99 and lets the market decide. Fair enough. I’ve heard a number of theories as to how she is getting these prices. My theory is simple: she has taken the time to build a brand and is reaping the reward - with a high percentage of her sales surely from deep-pocketed newer collectors who trust her and choose to overpay with a trusted source. I don’t subscribe to any of the nefarious theories being bandied about.
Blog
Mark B. Ledenbach's vintage Halloween collectibles blog.