The seller is being very optimistic in offering this as a BIN for $69.95. When valuing items, you must adjust for condition. On a typical day with this lantern in mint condition, sustainable guide value is $30. Given this lantern's condition, with an unfortunate crease across one side, I don't see that this should reasonably fetch more than a single Jackson.
Blog
Mark B. Ledenbach's vintage Halloween collectibles blog.
