Ebay is such an unpredictable marketplace. This is a very common punch game that surfaces regularly and typically fetches around $15. Why it brought $51 is a mystery.
Blog
Mark B. Ledenbach's vintage Halloween collectibles blog.
FABULOUS LG MARKED GERMANY PAPER MACHE BLACK CAT ON PUMPKIN CANDY CONTAINER
This seller has listed a number of very dubious Halloween items recently. Here is another one. This is not an old item, but one that has been recently manufactured somewhere, probably off-shore. It has none of the detailing characteristic of an truly vintage item. Unfortunately for some bidder, it has already reached a price of nearly $160 with 5+ hours to go. It has zero collectible value.
03/08 Update: This ended with some poor schmuck forking over $355.00 for what is a $10 decorative item.
German papermache pickel halloween noise maker
I've never understood why this would be considered Halloween related.
21" ~ WITCH ~ Nodder ~ Candy Container ~ #1 ~ 2008 ~ Kathy Patterson
Admittedly, this is an awesome and seemingly meticulously crafted piece of Halloween folk art. However, the seller has listed and re-listed this item (among other pieces of folk art) for many months, perhaps for over a year. It illustrates that the holiday folk art field is still developing with a very limited clientele for such high-end pieces. If the seller is serious about wanting to move this out to a new home, she'll have to drop the price, perhaps substantially.
30 VERY EARLY DENNISON HALLOWEEN SEALS IN ORIG ENVELOPE - ARCHED BLACK CATS
These are not "very early" seals. Dennison's packaging became quite plain and much cheaper to produce during the 1950s. Out went the slide boxes and in came these minimally decorated envelopes with the silver back seals. This set is from the later 1950s and into the early 1960s. They have a value that in no way approaches what this seller has as a BIN price.
Vtg Halloween Pop Out 3D Ghost Tombstone Paper Decoration Cardboard
Whomever bought this, and the two others to the set, got bargains. These typically fetch around $150. Even with the minor condition issues the photos reveal, $57 for this, the best of the trio, was an excellent purchase. Kudos to the buyer!!
VINTAGE HALLOWEEN CARDS SCAREY WINDOW HANGERS CLOWN AND CAT CARDBOARD
These two are from a set of eight small diecuts that Beistle issued in the early 1950s. In my view, the clown is the least interesting of all eight, but the cat with bells is a tough diecut to find. Be cognizant of condition whenever buying paper.
03/10 Update: These fetched a modest $44.12.
VINTAGE CARDBOARD HALLOWEEN WITCH LANTERN OR SHADE-TRIANGULAR-COOL
This is a shade made by the Gibson Art Company of Cincinnati, Ohio in 1929. It isn't complete. It is missing its perforated black construction paper disk that would slip over the three hat points to provide the shade with needed structural support. This is a hard-to-find item that typically would fetch $150-175 if in perfect condition.
FABULOUS LG ANTIQUE GERMAN SIGNED PAPER MACHE BLACK CAT CANDY CONTAINER
This isn't old. I notice that the seller makes no claim as to its age except for listing it in the vintage category. This doesn't have the correct finish, the requisite detail one would expect from an authentic German candy container or any of the charm. This has no collectible value in my opinion.
Vintage 1924 DENNISON'S BOGIE BOOK Of Suggestions for Halloween And Thanksgi
I wish that sellers would logically allow for the all-important consideration of "condition" when they list items for sale. Let's face it - this copy is darn ragged and in overall "good condition." Yet the seller imagines they'll garner bids at the opening price of $125.95, or perhaps will even entice some yokel to cough up $168..59 for what is a very sub-standard example of something that can typically be found in collectible condition. I'd suggest the seller re-list at $9.99 with no reserve and be thankful if the bidding reaches ~$60.
RARE FIND VINTAGE HALLOWEEN JOL CANDLE FANTASTIC GRAPHICS ON BOX PUMPKIN WITCH
This very cool box appears on page 84 of my second edition. The seller is correct - the box is rarely seen. In fact, fair value on the candle is around $15, while the box in perfect condition should fetch around $100. This particular box is in lesser condition, so it will be informative to see how the market values it during this very off season.
Rare Old Antique Brass Bed Warmer w Halloween Witch on Broom Design Eng Reg Mk
This is an interesting artifact. Given the seller's statement that is was made in England in the 1880s, it would have been too early to have been made for the American Halloween market, since one wasn't truly developed at that time. Nonetheless, I can see this easily fitting into a collection even though the design is in the tradition of an English interest in supernatural beings rather than any intended connection to what we now celebrate as Halloween.
Antique Child's Hallowe'en JOL Teapot German
Even with a re-glued lid, whomever bought this German porcelain tea pot, made sometime between 1908-1932, got a true bargain. The paint has more of a matte finish than normal, but it was still a nice addition to a collection for about one-third of its typical value.
Pair of circa 1920's 30's Halloween Cloth (Felt?) hats
This is merely one of hundreds of possible examples of Ebay sellers crossing their fingers and asking for the moon for items that aren't worth much. This listing has a BIN price of $270.00 with an accompanying "Make Offer" button. I wonder how serious the seller is in considering reasonable offers. A reasonable offer for this lot of two non-descript felt hats in damaged condition is perhaps $30.
Old German Porcelain Halloween Pumpkin covered box Jack o Lantern
This is a rare jam pot from the adult-sized porcelain "tea set" made in Germany as early as about 1914. This is only the second time in 26 years of collecting that I have seen this item. (I bought the one in the collection several years ago in a private sale.) This one has a number of surface flaws but brought what I consider to be a strong price nonetheless. The Germans made three sizes of these porcelain sets. The largest, to which this jam pot belongs, was marketed to adults. Any pieces from this set are extremely desirable. Kudos to the prevailing bidder!!
