This is only the second time I have seen this iteration of a black cat face German diecut. The other time was just a few days ago on Ebay. (That listing consisted of two diecuts. Considering it was snapped up for only $181, I feel collectors simply overlooked it.) The eyes on this iteration look down whereas the eyes on the most common of the three designs look straight at the viewer and the eyes on the second-most common look to the right. Each iteration has a different design on the hat. Given how rare this diecut is, it should fetch no less than $225.
Mark B. Ledenbach's vintage Halloween collectibles blog.