This game, made by Beistle in the 1930s, is not terribly hard-to-find. The fact that this game brought $535.99 is an example of the sometimes crazed nature of Ebay. This result is a definite outlier. The seller should be ecstatic at landing a big fish. The fish needs to bone up on relative scarcity and current values, else they will have a very expensively put together small collection.
Mark B. Ledenbach's vintage Halloween collectibles blog.